How to Use an SWR
Understanding how to use a SWR meter is relatively easy, but sometimes knowing how to interpret the results and their limitations enables far more to be gained from using a SWR meter.
There are many different SWR meters that are available, often aimed at the CB and amateur radio markets.
Some very low cost items are available, but sometimes it may be better to pay a little more and obtained a better quality instrument.
SWR meters are normally one and the same thing. Current and voltage standing waves are set up when power is reflected from a mismatch, and often their is a focus on the voltage elements.
When looking at how to use a SWR meter, most instructions are fairly vague, often just detailing which connector is to be connected to the antenna and which connector to the transmitter.
The basic set-up for a SWR meter is as shown in the diagram below.
The SWR meter is connected in the feeder from the transmitter to the antenna. Typically it is located at the transmitter end of the feeder for convenience, and so that the actual SWR as seen by the transmitter can be monitored.
The easiest way to achieve this is to connect the antenna plug normally connected to the transmitter into the SWR meter socket labelled ANT or ANTENNA, and then use a short patch lead to connect the socket marked TX or TRANSMITTER on the SWR meter to the transmitter.
In some instances an antenna matching / tuning unit may be used. Again for convenience these are often placed near the transmitter. It is often more convenient to place an ATU close to the transmitter as having a remote one often means getting power to it and also weather-proofing it and this adds significant cost.
When an ATU or antenna matching and tuning unit is added to the set-up, the system shown below is normally used. By placing the SWR meter between the transmitter and the ATU, the SWR it sees is monitored. This is normally the most critical point to monitor the SWR because high SWR levels can damage the power amplifiers if no protection is incorporated, or it can result in the protection circuits backing off the power.
The effect of the ATU is to reduce the SWR as seen by the transmitter. It does not improve the SWR that is seen on the antenna side of the SWR meter. However it is found that if the coax feeder can withstand the higher voltages and current as a result of the poor antenna match, and the feeder loss is not too high, then the system will work well.
How to use the SWR meter
Actually using the SWR meter is very easy, but a few simple steps may help the first time user.
When using the SWR meter to measure the performance of a new antenna or where the SWR may not be know, it is wise to use a low power and a clear channel. With these concepts in mind the following procedure may be useful.
- Find a clear channel or frequency: It is worth listening for a short while in case you cannot hear one station in a two way contact
- Reduce power: Reduce the output power from the transmitter. This needs to be done in case there is a poor SWR and it will reduce the likelihood of possible damage to the output devise of the transmitter.
- Set mode switch: Set the mode switch to a mode where a constant output is given, e.g. CW, AM or FM. In this way a steady reading is given. For CW (Morse) the key will need to be held down.
- Set SWR meter: the SWR meter switch on the front panel to FORWARD, and turn the adjustment or CAL knob down – this prevents overloading the meter.
- Adjust forward reading: With the transmitter transmitting, adjust the knob on the CAL or adjustment knob so that a full scale reading is obtained.
- Switch meter to reverse : With the meter calibrated for the forward power, switch the meter to its reverse position and read the SWR.
- Stop transmitting : It is good practice to stop transmitting as soon as possible. This reduces the possibility of interference to other stations and also reduces the overload on the transmitter output if the SWR is poor.
- Check on other frequencies: If a wide band of frequencies or channels is to be used, then check the VSWR readings for the other frequencies or channels to be used because the SWR will change over a range of frequencies.
- Remember: When transmitting on full power, it is often useful to leave the SWR meter in circuit, but remember to calibrate it for the higher power output. Changes of power mean that the forward power needs to be reset using the CAL knob.
What is a bad SWR?
There is no general pass or fail mark when measuring SWR. SWR is measured as a ratio, i.e. 1:1 for no reflected power, 2:1, 3:1 and so forth. An open or a short circuit will be Infinite :1.
Often SWR meters will have a red calibration above 3:1 and this is probably the maximum you would want a transmitter to run with. A maximum of 2:1 would be better to prevent damage to the transmitter if it does not have protection on the output circuitry. Check the transmitter handbook in case there are guidelines on the maximum SWR that the unit can work with.
But in reality there are no hard and fast rules. In general, the lower the better, but there will be very little difference in signal at the receiver between a SWR of 1:1 and 2:1.
Where to measure SWR
It is important to know the best place to measure the SWR for ease, seeing what SWR is seen by the transmitter, and how the antenna is performing.
Unfortunately these requirements do not coincide and therefore it is necessary to understand what happens and how the SWR measurements and readings can be distorted.
The main issue is the feeder loss that is always present to a greater or lesser degree. This can have a major effect on the SWR readings that are seen.
Any feeder loss absorbs power in both directions, and a high level of feeder loss can mean that the reflected signal is much reduced. It is reduced as a forward signal to the antenna, and then again as a reflected signal back to the transmitter.
This means that an antenna with a poor match and a very high SWR may appear as being fine at the transmitter because the signal is reduced on its way to the antenna, and even thought he same percentage of power is reflected, it is the same percentage of a smaller amount. This means that with a feeder that introduces a high loss the SWR can seem good at the transmitter, but at the antenna itself it may be very poor.
As an example take the example of a transmitter transmitting 100 watts through a feeder with a loss of 3 dB. This means that only 50 watts reaches the antenna. If the antenna has a poor match and the resulting SWR is 8:1, i.e. 60% or 30 watts of the power is reflected. This is further attenuated by 3 dB meaning that only 15 watts reflected power is seen at the transmitter.
The reflected power has been attenuated by 2 x 3dB, i.e. 6 dB and this means that a SWR at the antenna of 8:1 is seen at the transmitter as a SWR of 2.2:1 which is not bad. In other words the high feeder loss makes it appear as if the antenna is functioning well.
Diagram showing how feeder loss can improve the SWR seen at the transmitter end of the feeder
Points to note when using a SWR meter
There are several points to note as well as some useful hints and tips when measuring SWR.
- Ensure meter connectors are correctly connected: Make sure that the ANT or ANTENNA connection is connected to the antenna, and the TX or TRANSMITTER connection links to the transmitter. The other way round and the forward and reverse positions on the switch will seem to be reversed.
- Don’t operate into a high SWR: Be careful not to operate into a high SWR as damage can result to the transmitter, and occasionally the feeder.
- Ensure meter has correct frequency range: SWR meters are typically designed to operate over a given frequency range. Using them outside this range can mean they are insufficiently sensitive and the full scale defection in the forward direction may be difficult to achieve.
- Understanding how to use a SWR meter is normally very easy. A few simple steps is all that is required to connect it and set it up. Once this has been done, then it can be left in circuit if needed.
- In many instances it is good to leave a SWR meter of some form in circuit so that checks can quickly be made, and if there are any intermittent faults, these can be flagged up very quickly.
SWR to return loss & return loss to SWR table
It is often necessary to convert SWR to return loss or return loss to SWR. The conversion can be achieved quite easily using either simple formulas, or using a table of values.
Return Loss and SWR are both parameters used to measure the match between a feeder and a load, although the two quantities are slightly different.
The SWR is a measure of the standing waves set up in a feeder as a result of a mismatch, whereas the return loss looks at the amount of power absorbed by a load when power from a source is sent to it. The return loss being the difference between the incident power and the reflected.
In view of the overlap between the two quantities it is useful to be able to convert SWR to return loss and return loss to SWR.
It is sometimes easier to undertake the conversions between return loss and SWR using a table. Values of retrun loss to SWR and SWR to return loss can be read off for most useable values required within the table.
|SWR to Return Loss and Return Loss to SWR
|SWR||Voltage Reflection Coefficient|
SWR and return loss are both ways of expressing power reflected as a result of impedance mismatches. SWR to return loss and return loss to SWR conversions are often needed.